I may have been confusing in my last post. Maybe this will clarify it:

Part # for the Storage Bin replacement is 1BQ12XDVAA

Part # for the Cup Holder is 0ZC59XZAA (I received this number from my local Chrysler dealership and can get this from them at a cost of $259)

Part # for a Cup Holder on Ebay is 1CG68XZAAA (the description on Ebay says its for 2006-2008 and costs $167)

I would prefer to replace my broken cup holder with another cup holder as opposed to the replacement storage bin. My question is will the cup holder on Ebay with part number 1CG68XZAAA work for a 2005 or is it only for a 2006-2008?