I can def see the dilemma that you are having. I work at a dodge chrysler jeep dealership so I had a lot of resources to check them out. But even after finding the same things as you, I still bought it. I have just turned 20 and I wouldn't trade mine for the world. I have only had my xfire for about 2 weeks but already I know it was the right choice. You do need to think about all the upkeep though. It is not cheep. But do not let that discourage you. Just keep it in mind when you make you decision. And forget the srt4. They are in our shop for more work than you can imagine. The xfire is on a whole nether level. And get the 6 speed by the way...