UPDATE:

So, I took the car back to the dealer. Their interior repair guy was able to fix everything. I don't know what technique he used, but the interior looks brand new. All that coated plastic that scuffs so easily is back to brand new again. Here's the new problems though. It's almost funny now. When he taped off the silver plastic on the console, the tape removed the clear coat and finish! He used the blue painter's tape, I saw it! The whole interior is very fragile in these cars. Also, he couldn't repair the door panel. The dealership has ordered a new door panel and center console piece. This time I got the rental and the full attention from the sales manager. She has been great! Still surprised they haven't offered a free oil change or something. Oh, I gave up on the original problem of the seatbelt alarm not working. I don't miss it. So, all in all, I got a new interior out of all of this for free. Their scratches are fixed and some that were already there as well, because the tech couldn't just re-coat small sections, had to do the whole thing. Still a bunch of B.S. I missed an entire month and a half of this car. Up here, that is precious time before the snow comes.