I'd prefer the coupe especially if I roll her over . Either one is great but at 6'2" and 250lbs I know for a fact the roadster is easier to get into. When I was shopping I wanted the convertable but my wife liked the coupe, being the coupe was 23,999 and had 40 miles on it and the convertable was 33,999 with 40 miles on it, I didn't even try to argue.