Caught: well, you don't HAVE to use 19" on back & 18" on front. There are some members who have opted for equal size on both front & rear.

As to the initial question: I have Goodyear F1 All-Seasons on the SRT & Dunlop All-Seasons on the Coupe. Gotta say I like the Goodyears better simply because they're quieter. Both perform well in sloppy weather though I haven't had a chance to drive the Goodyear's in snow yet. Frankly, I try NOT to drive either car in the snow but there are those times when you get caught by a surprise snowfall.........