Thanks for all of the feedback guys!
I was seriously considering the Vanilla, but after spending the last week in the 2 tone gray, I might end up going with that. I'm pretty nervous about the white and how much maintenance it may be, especially with the steering wheel. I think it looks so hot, but the gray just seems much more low maintenance.
Turns out we're ordering it this Friday; so I'll let you know for sure what I end up with!