Thanks for all the help guys - I ended up ordering it from the dealer for less than five bucks. Definitely a better alternative to the 12 dollars I would have ended up spending at chryslerpartsdirect.com.
Originally Posted by Nexxus
Easiest thing is what I did: Simply remove the other one and get a small amount of gloss black and paint the screws. After doing it I never noticed the caps missing again, and it looks factory.
I may end up doing this if I lose another cap
.