I hate to say this, but boy am I glad I am 50 and live in Ohio!!!!
I pay $927.00 per year w/ $500 deductible for both our cars. A 2004 Crossfire ($595.00) and a 2002 Hundai Santa Fe ($332.00). The carrier is State Auto Insurance.
My rate increased a whopping $20.00 per year when I eliminated the 2001 Mitsubishi Eclipse and added the Crossfire.....
I guess there is some advantage to living where it is "kinda cold" and I have to shovel snow now and then!!!!