Shapeshifter
Thanks for starting this thread.
My 2007 is still under warranty but I would rather fix it myself considering Chryslers lack of body parts. Some members have been waiting months for bumpers. Yesterday one of our members posted that he brought his car in for a crank sensor and the mechanic cracked his engine cover. They dont have them on the shelf either. If I can fix it myself I will .
Anyway, as I said last night I used Meguairs scratch X over a year ago, and it still looks fine.
I see your Vin is 72277,Winstons is 73307, and mine(Joejet) is 71597. I don't see a trend.
Lets try this my, car was built in 01-07. How about everyone with a 2007 Black base coupe post your Vin and month it was built. Maybe we can figure it out from that angle.

Joejet
if your here, you know the year,model,and color.71597