Ok went to home depot, got a #1 extractor, proper size drill bit (2 mm), and two replacement steel bolts. Took my time, thank God the extractor worked, and the broken bolt came right out. Spent a few hours sanding off the sealant I put on it, resealed it, set it, and the new bolts went in just fine.

Thanks so much for the help and advice everyone!!!! Love this forum!