Re: Gearbox Noise ?
So much trouble and anger! If it really was the gearbox and nothing else, I wouldn't doubt about replacing it. In the factory they do assemble the parts together as well. There's only one major input shaft from the engine. It was probably not affected by the malfunction. Must be able to check this respective conjunction. Furthermore you mentioned in your first post that the clutch was involved and it only occurred when idling in the neutral. Thus not really a matter of the gearbox itself.
If everything else is fine with your xf, go for the replacement. You still have warranty if the desired change doesn't occur.
Good luck.
Last edited by chxf; May 31, 2005 at 08:52 AM.