In my opinion (Having driven the Crossfire) That Brit from Top Gear doesn't know a Steering wheel from a brake peddle. The Automatic tranny is absolutely awesome!!! I've also driven the RX8 and it rides like a buckboard. And don't even think about leaving the line quick with the RX unless you rev the crap out of it.

If you drive both cars you won't have any problem picking the one that serves your purpose and style the best.

But whatever you do... Don't let the so called "Experts" tell you which one is best. Only you can determin what is the best fit for you.