I have the Noah. Repels light rain well, but medium to heavy rain will soak through. It's breathable, so it does dry out. It's heavy enough to protect against scratches, but I don't think anything will stop dents. Although it's a perfect, tight custom fit the the SRT roadster, in heavy winds you need to have the cable lock running under the car or air will get under the cover and the front will come off (often followed by the rear!) In your hurricane winds, even with the lock on, you will return to your car to find the cover off of the front and back with only the cable keeping it from being 2 counties away!

After 2 years in the weather (late spring-late fall...garaged during winter), the wind rubbing on the convertible top causes the under side of the cover to get fuzzy and leave lint on the top. Mine is a weekend nice weather driver, so it spent way more time under the cover than being driven (currently 6500 miles). I'm going to have my friend's Mom, who's a seamstress, sew a piece of nylon or non-linting material on the underside of the cover just where the convertible top is, because the lint drives me crazy! If it was truely waterproof, I would worry about her stitching breaking the water barrier in the cover exterior, but like I said, it's water resistent!

I'd buy another one. I think it has held up well given the amount of weather it has seen. I did expect it to be a little more water "proof", but I guess if it's got to breathe, then it's going to let the heavy rain through. It's also protected the car well from the sun (no foggy headlight lense), bird droppings, fall leaves, fireworks, etc.

One suggestion i can give is for placing the antenna grommet. You have to cut a small hole where the antenna is and place a plastic grommet (supplied with cover) on the hole to keep the cover from tearing. I put the cover on as best as I could with the antenna still attached to the car and then eye-balled the hole location. After I cut the whole (slightly off from where I really needed it), I realized that the stock antenna just unscrews. I should have unscrewed the antenna, put the cover on, felt through the cover for the antenna base and then cut the grommet hole exactly where it needed to be. Since my hole was off by an inch and a half or so, it put unnecessary stress on the cover at the grommet and the cover did tear a little after about 1.5 years. Just enough to relieve the stress, but it's still a 1.5 inch tear!

I can't speak of the other covers, but I wanted to give my review of the Noah since I saw you had a convertible and the lint after 2 years use drives me crazy. Coupes shouldn't have any problems!
Mike