Re: Does this sound Honest/legal to you?
I believe that if a company gives you rebates or what ever they want to call them, you have paid too much to begin with. They are giving you back some of your money and make out they are being good to you.
If they really wanted to be good to you they would have charged you a fair price to begin with.
These days accountants rule and a bad deal can be made to look like they have found the goose that lays the golden eggs.
Ask an accountant what one plus one is and he'll reply 'anything you want it to'.