Sorry to hear about your accident I just recently had an incident involving a deer and I had the bumper replaced with out a problem I'll give you the garage phone number that I used maybe they have connections beyond those of the garage your using.

Gatesman Auto Body - CARSTAR - Clarion County's Best Auto Body Repair Shop
(814) 226-9468

Ask for Dana or Dj

My name is Jerid Kerle
They will remember me and the car I'm sure!!! My experience with their work wasn't great Im still pretty pissed about it so don't hand them any money for anything lol You may find them helpful for locating parts tho... Good luck!!!