Jonathan - I just read this thread! I am really sorry that this happened. I am glad that Murfi wasn't with you and that you are ok.
Don't let the insurance company low ball you on an offer. I just booked out your car in black book for the Southeast (book date 10/03/2011).
Clean Black Book 12075
Avg Black Book 10675
Rough Black Book 7450
These are wholesale values, not replacement value. Our cars have gone up in value a LOT in the last year (the whole market is up). Let me know if you need me to fax you a copy of the book.
NADA wholesale is a little better.
Clean NADA 12450
Avg NADA 11425
Rough NADA 10175
I think you should be able to get enough out of this car to pay for a roadster (yellow is the best
)