Originally Posted by Mike-in-Orange
Out of everything you've mentioned - Caymen S, end of story. You're not going to find a better looking, better balanced car out there. No, it's not the fastest thing on the road but if all you care about is horsepower go ask John Force if he has anything for sale. If you want a beautiful looking, beautifully built, fantastic handling sports car for well under $100K, that's the one to go with.
The Evora would be a close second in my book, but I detest the thought of a Toyota engine in my garage.
Like I said, that is the leading contender. I like HP but the car has to handle! And it has to look good. Number one priority is it has to be fun to drive.
Lexus IS "F" is a sedan so it is out of the running. Only interested in 2 door coupes. Keep the suggestions coming! Good stuff.