While tire tests may be subjective, every source I have come across gives the edge to the Goodyear Eagle F1's. Car and driver tested 11 brands and they too put the F1's in first place...

http://www.caranddriver.com/article....ticle_id=10252

OVERALL SCORE

Goodyear: 1050.4
Continental: 1031.9
Yokohama: 1027.0
Michelin: 1018.7
Hankook: 1015.4
Dunlop: 1002.2
Pirelli: 1002.1
Toyo: 999.7
Bridgestone: 993.9
BFGoodrich: 993.0
Kumho: 990.7