I love mine, had it since 08, bought it with 585 miles on it and 2 years old. It sounds like you are looking at cars that the previous owners did not care to do maint. Mine looks like it did when I got it except for mods. I will say mine is a weekend car, and I care what happens to it.
Shift your price up a little, look in lots of places( ebay, Autotraders, this forum, etc.). you can find a great car that you will love everyday you get to see it. Join up with a forum group in your area and go to GTGs, and have fun.