Old Sep 4, 2012 | 08:17 PM
  #37 (permalink)  
onehundred80's Avatar
onehundred80
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 25,432
Likes: 650
From: Ontario
Default Re: Mobil 1 filter vs. Mann filter vs. Purolator filter

Originally Posted by +fireamx
I've always kind of thought the same way Mike in Orange felt, to a point.
I'm pretty religious about using "factory" brand filters on all my cars. I go to the Honda dealer for its filter, I pick up an AC Delco filter for my Chevy Van, Mazda dealer for our Miata, and usually a Mercedes dealer for the Crossfire. (But I have used Mann filters as well since I understand they make the factory filter). Still having a hard time finding an AMC dealer for my AMX oil filter though.
I've pretty much went along with the general rule here on the forum that the fleece filter is better than a paper one, but in the back of my mind, I can't help thinking, Isn't a layer of paper less pourous than a layer of fleece?
If that is so, then wouldn't a layer of paper capture more impurities than a layer of fleece.
This 'fleece' did not come from the back of a sheep, so the density could be anything they wanted to make it.

I have just cut up a used Mann fleece filter, rather messy, and it looks like a paper element with a mesh bonded on the inside of the paper. So basically it is the same as the others but made out of a different material. It of course is sparkling white when new and the others look like some paper towels in color.

Overall they probably do just as good a job if they are the extended life type. As I said before you pay your money and take your choice.
 
Reply