It's really all in what you like. It looks like the '05 has fog lights, so I would assume it's the Limited which should compare to the '04 as far as features. They have comparable mileage and are both coupes, so you are down to color, transmission and history. Which do you prefer? Each transmission have their pros and cons, so it is up to you to decide what's important to you. Are you able to get a Car-Fax on them to see if there are any reported problems? That may help make a decision. Hard to tell from a few picks and a write up from the owner trying to sell the car. Try to dig into them and find something wrong with them. If you can't find anything, at least you have done your best to make a good decision.

Good luck!!

RL