Results of Autotrader search 10PM 3-12-14
search parameters: Nationwide, coupe, 2004-2008, under 45,000 miles, under $10,000:


3 results:


'05 37,610 miles $9898


'05 42,000 miles $8500


'04 44,000 miles $9995


Seems to me the OP's car is underpriced, but maybe I'm biased since my car is very similar to OP's.
Or maybe the search results are indicative of competitive value in the marketplace.