It's funny, I didn't take much offence to what the BMW driver said either. It's obvious he wasn't familiar with the car, and he was just voicing his opinion that's all.
I know it's all a matter of taste, but personally I don't feel the XF roadster looks that bad with the top up. Most all roadsters look better with their top down, that's a given. But I think the XF looks far better than the Corvette does with its top up. Even better than my Miata (sorry Cissy) also.
Markr6754, you're not alone when it comes to the Chrysler 300. IMO, It's one of the few cars that the factory "Pimps Your Ride" for you at no extra cost.
Also, I fully understand the reasoning behind owning 2 Harleys. It never hurts to have a spare (just kidding).
My only real concern about the BMW driver that posted his opinions on the BMW forum is this. If it took him 15 minutes to figure out where the outside rearview mirror adjusters were, then I hope his dealer never gives him a SAAB as a loner.