Oh i fought with them! They said there is no way there machine did that and I had to of hit a pot hole. I told him I think I would know if I hit a pot hole in my car. I did go to another tire shop at home where I know the mechanic and he assured me there machine does not touch that part of wheel. So I am gonna suck it up. Just bough the one on ebay. New for $185.00 ughhh!!! Oh well.