Hi Jim, I'm not familiar with the two company's dash kit products you mentioned. After years of wavering on what to do with the "river of silver", I recently pulled the trigger at DashKitMall.com and bought two sets of their real black carbon fiber Crossfire kits (one for each of my roadsters). I was skeptical about the looks / quality of a stick on dash kit but was very pleasantly surprised. Great fit and quality. All the carbon fiber pattern lines up on their adjacent pieces. VERY HAPPY. Note: The kit includes more pieces to do the dash and glove box area but I chose to only install the pieces on the "river of silver" center console and center stack.