you are both right in this case. It's a 15 year old car, so there are going to be some minor items.....a scratch here, a frayed stich there, maybe even a light bulb (gasp!). That is to be expected. A serious buyer isn't going to let that type of minor stuff bother them. Maybe they offer a couple hundred less because of what they see in person. No big deal. But when it comes to something major, like mechanicals, the top, tires, paint, accidents, clear title, etc, then I will list anything I see wrong that might actually influence a buyers decision. That is why the ad mentions needing tires in the next few thousand miles.
it also makes it a little harder that I'm not near the car. I know the car, it's a great car, well priced, described accurately, but I can't necessarily answer for very minor details like that. At some point, a buyer needs to be willing to come look at the car, or not. LOL.
Thank you. .