Which mats did you ultimately go with? Lloyds is awesome because you can customize them and they look GREAT and last long.

Some folks, depending on where you live, might want rubber mats. They are also out there in various editions. On my old Coupe I went with Rubber Mercedes SLK mats. They fit. Found them on EBay and really liked the look of them. They were inexpensive, too ($49 for a set, brand new).
Just depends on what you are looking for.