Too much safety?
Considering the modest power output of the Xfire, does anyone else think all the safety features are overkill? I'm all for a safe car, but traction & stability control - that "learns" driver behavior - just seems like overkill. It's not like this is some dangerous, tire-shredding torque monster. Seems like needless extra weight and complexity that could cut into performance. I've driven all kinds of cars, including RWD, in every type of weather and I've never wrecked one. I'd be all for a little less safety and a little more zip. Still love the car, though.
Originally Posted by Louie K
I don't think so-not only can you turn it off, but how much can wires and a module add to the weight of a car? Under 10 pounds I'd assume...
Originally Posted by Mediacritic
Probably true, but you can't really turn it completely off. Do we need all this protection from 215 hp?
Too much safety, what are you nuts? It's not the horsepower that will kill you it is speed that will punch your ticket. I for one really appreciate the safety features incorporated into the Crossfire especially when cruising on a mountain road or coastal highway and come up on a curve while you're doing 2X the posted speed and catch a little gravel or you have deer pop out on the road. The car may not be as powerful as others in it's class but it sure can handle curves and is very stable even in emergency circumstances.
Originally Posted by Mediacritic
Probably true, but you can't really turn it completely off. Do we need all this protection from 215 hp?
Last edited by BrianBrave; Aug 17, 2007 at 04:26 PM.
Originally Posted by Mediacritic
Probably true, but you can't really turn it completely off. Do we need all this protection from 215 hp?
Amazing how things change. About a year ago there were a number of (young aggressive) driver's that were advocating leaving it in the off position because it "interfered" with their spirited driving techniques. They convinced one of the members to write how much "better" the car handled without it, "...especially in the rain!" ...WRONG!!!
Woody and others put it very clearly. I fell it can be equated to anti-lock braking systems. They are great and have saved me from a collision a couple times. But, there have been reports of people misunderstanding their use and driving more aggressively because they think the ALB system will save them.
For doing "dirty donuts" and track events, turn the TC/SC off otherwise leave it on...glad to have it.
Woody and others put it very clearly. I fell it can be equated to anti-lock braking systems. They are great and have saved me from a collision a couple times. But, there have been reports of people misunderstanding their use and driving more aggressively because they think the ALB system will save them.
For doing "dirty donuts" and track events, turn the TC/SC off otherwise leave it on...glad to have it.
ESP and ABS are (in the USA) federally mandated to be on ALL vehicles come 2008.
These are required by law... what you do with them after that is up to you.
To the turning off traction control for 'Dirty Donuts'... Woody actually was able to turn off the ESP entirely (hack or disconnected module and sensors). I will be doing the same soon for a little 'fun' in a circle as I bid farewell to my old tires.
I WILL put it all back for daily driving though as those systems are there for a reason. Loosing control of a vehicle in a crowded urban environment = bad. At the track I may even get brave enough to turn off the traction control by it's switch, but I have a ways to go to get to the point where I will disable ESP while on the track... I mean I still have to learn how to trail brake!
To each their own... but be safe... *HUGS*
These are required by law... what you do with them after that is up to you.
To the turning off traction control for 'Dirty Donuts'... Woody actually was able to turn off the ESP entirely (hack or disconnected module and sensors). I will be doing the same soon for a little 'fun' in a circle as I bid farewell to my old tires.
I WILL put it all back for daily driving though as those systems are there for a reason. Loosing control of a vehicle in a crowded urban environment = bad. At the track I may even get brave enough to turn off the traction control by it's switch, but I have a ways to go to get to the point where I will disable ESP while on the track... I mean I still have to learn how to trail brake!
To each their own... but be safe... *HUGS*
EXACTLY!!!
Try this trick...
The next time it rains, find an empty parking lot (BIG ONE) and get the car up to about 40 MPH and YANK the Steering wheel as hard and fast as you can and see what happens...
Now do the same thing with the ESP OFF. Now, after you change your underwear, you can tell me how it has no place in these cars...
Try this trick...
The next time it rains, find an empty parking lot (BIG ONE) and get the car up to about 40 MPH and YANK the Steering wheel as hard and fast as you can and see what happens...
Now do the same thing with the ESP OFF. Now, after you change your underwear, you can tell me how it has no place in these cars...
Eh safety takes a away the fun... you just have to decide for yourself what is more important to you, but I guess like many things the government believes that it is better that it makes the decision and not you...
Now what would really be great is that button for traction control on or even more on could actually be on or off...
Now what would really be great is that button for traction control on or even more on could actually be on or off...
Originally Posted by BrianBrave
What do you expect from a Hillary Clinton-Rodham supporter? All you can say is that Medacritic is a Type-A adrenaline risk taker!
Originally Posted by woody
Most of this stuff comes as an integral part of the latest engine management systems that the manufacturers source from Bosch and Marelli et al. In Europe you even get ESP/TC BAS/ABS on 70 HP superminis. It effectively costs very little for the manufacturer to implement and fills out the spec sheet very nicely. It undoubtedly saves lives but I think it gives people a false sense of security. It can save people from situations they should never have got into in the first place, and they won't even be aware that it happened.
Originally Posted by Mediacritic
Who said I support HRC?
So, I guess if you do support the HRC, then at least we know what team you catch for, not that there is anything wrong with that...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Kodebuster
Wheels, Brakes, Tires and Suspension
12
Nov 5, 2020 04:06 PM
dbooso
Troubleshooting & Technical Questions & Modifications
9
Aug 27, 2015 11:03 AM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)




