Chirp from the sc clutch?
Chirp from the sc clutch?
I've been noticing a consistent noise. I haven't really paid too much attention to it until now, but I think what I'm hearing is a chirp from the sc clutch engaging. It only happens in 1st gear when I'm in manual mode. It doesn't matter how fast or slow I accelerate, but when I hit right around 3k rpm, I hear a chirp and feel a massive shove in torque. I think before I thought that it was just wheel spin from the surge in torque, but now I think it's the clutch engaging. If I rev over the 3k and it happens and then decelerate and try to hit 3k to hear it again it doesn't happen, unless I come to a stop and accelerate again. Now, I've read a thread or two over on mbworld and they said the chirp was normal as the clutch and pulley age, but I would assume the clutch should be engaging somewhere between 1600-1800 rpm. If what I'm hearing is my clutch engaging, I don't know why it's not engaging until 3000 rpm. Should I be concerned? Any thoughts are appreciated.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
I've been noticing a consistent noise. I haven't really paid too much attention to it until now, but I think what I'm hearing is a chirp from the sc clutch engaging. It only happens in 1st gear when I'm in manual mode. It doesn't matter how fast or slow I accelerate, but when I hit right around 3k rpm, I hear a chirp and feel a massive shove in torque. I think before I thought that it was just wheel spin from the surge in torque, but now I think it's the clutch engaging. If I rev over the 3k and it happens and then decelerate and try to hit 3k to hear it again it doesn't happen, unless I come to a stop and accelerate again. Now, I've read a thread or two over on mbworld and they said the chirp was normal as the clutch and pulley age, but I would assume the clutch should be engaging somewhere between 1600-1800 rpm. If what I'm hearing is my clutch engaging, I don't know why it's not engaging until 3000 rpm. Should I be concerned? Any thoughts are appreciated.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
I've been noticing a consistent noise. I haven't really paid too much attention to it until now, but I think what I'm hearing is a chirp from the sc clutch engaging. It only happens in 1st gear when I'm in manual mode. It doesn't matter how fast or slow I accelerate, but when I hit right around 3k rpm, I hear a chirp and feel a massive shove in torque. I think before I thought that it was just wheel spin from the surge in torque, but now I think it's the clutch engaging. If I rev over the 3k and it happens and then decelerate and try to hit 3k to hear it again it doesn't happen, unless I come to a stop and accelerate again. Now, I've read a thread or two over on mbworld and they said the chirp was normal as the clutch and pulley age, but I would assume the clutch should be engaging somewhere between 1600-1800 rpm. If what I'm hearing is my clutch engaging, I don't know why it's not engaging until 3000 rpm. Should I be concerned? Any thoughts are appreciated.
You are using the Polish 65 mm pulley from what I have read on your posts, is it possible that there is a problem somewhere on it? I am not saying there is but I would inspect it and see that the magnet has not been damaged like Red Dogs one was some time back and that it is affecting the clutch operation. Worth a look I would say.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
I guess I'll have to take the pulley and scattershield off so I can take a gander at the magnet. I never thought about it being the tensioner, but I don't really understand how it could be that. Why would a failing tensioner make a single chirp noise at 3k rpms, but not one at 2k or 5k? Isn't the tensioner at a constant tension all the time? Would the bolt being loose on the tensioner cause the chirp? Do you guys think too large of a pulley gap could cause this problem? Just thinking about possibilities.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
I changed belt with OEM and sway bar end links and chirp is gone now. I know with the belts they all different sizes cause the aftermarket one I had on was making chirping noise at low rpm
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
Once I put new belt from dealer, and changed front end links it went away now. It was only making chirp below 2000
Hope this helps.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
It seemed like when car got 1600-1800 rpm or when sc engages I would get chirp, when I changed 2 things at same time belt from mb dealership, and front end links it went away. I used to a clicking noise cmg from front brakes, someone put pads on with no shims and they would slide around and click
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
I checked it yesterday, and the gap was now UNDER .2mm!! (The SC still spun freely with the engine off, and I could stop the SC clutch with my bare hands when the engine was running, but I didnt like that the feeler gauge was such a tight fit between the clutch and back of the pulley)).
As a precaution, I installed 1 shim (they're .1mm thick) and now I have slightly less than a .3mm gap, maybe .28mm or so. So far, the SC spins freely with the car off, and the car runs and drives very normally).
So Im wondering (since you have the same pulley, bbsrt6) if maybe you have too MUCH gap, causing the SC to engage abruptly? It certainly would explain the torque shove you describe if the SC is not engaging around 1200rpm or so.
(You didnt mention if the car is making "normal SRT power" under 3000rpm).
Just a thought from a Xfire noob.
Last edited by Nikko; 09-11-2016 at 08:59 AM.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
Nikko: I don't have a feeler gauge but the pulley is damn close to the clutch from the looks of it. My factory pulley came with 1 shim, so when I installed the polish pulley, I just used the 1 shim. The incorrect gap theory makes the most sense to me, but I'm wondering about something. At what point is the gap too big to where the clutch won't engage at all? Now you asked if my car has the srt power below 3k rpms, and to be honest I can't tell because 1st gear is too short. It feels fast everywhere in 1st gear, but I do feel a noticeable shove at 3k.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
When it was intermittent, the dropping in and out of the power increase SC provides was EXTREMELY noticeable... like when it went out, a Prius would probably have blown my doors off, and that might not even be an exaggeration.
Before I changed the circulator pump, when SC would disengage abruptly at or near full throttle, even my wife said "what the #&(@ was THAT"??? I mean, it felt like I turned the key off, the dropoff was so dramatic.
It certainly SOUNDS like your blower is not engaging when it should, but based on how my car reacted when the pump was out completely, I'd think if the blower is not engaging at all below 3k rpm, the lack of power below 3k would be very obvious.
Measuring the gap with a feeler gauge seems to be of obvious importance, but even Code 3's instructions say "check the gap between the backplate and the clutch. It should be between .20 and .30mm. The important point is that once tightened, the pulley and clutch spin freely of each other, while being as close as possible".
Before I added a shim yesterday, the SC to backplate gap WAS under .20mm, but the SC did spin freely, and I could still stop the SC clutch with my bare hands when the engine was running. Makes me wonder if I really needed the shim at all?? Without the shim, the SC engagement was really smooth and undetectable when driving. It still is now that the shim is in, but it makes me wonder if there would be increased wear or stretching with the pulley springs.
I guess we'd also have to factor in some room to accommodate heat expansion, so who knows??
Anyway, I hope some of this might be of help.
Last edited by Nikko; 09-11-2016 at 02:59 PM.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
Hey BB. The one thing I might be able to add to this is that about 2 months ago, the SC circulator pump in my SRT initially became intermittent, and then crapped out altogether. That, of course, made the SC initially engage intermittently, and it quickly went to not engaging at all, due to the higher intake temp. (It went from fully functioning, to intermittent to totally non-functioning in the space of about 15 minutes).
When it was intermittent, the dropping in and out of the power increase SC provides was EXTREMELY noticeable... like when it went out, a Prius would probably have blown my doors off, and that might not even be an exaggeration.
Before I changed the circulator pump, when SC would disengage abruptly at or near full throttle, even my wife said "what the #&(@ was THAT"??? I mean, it felt like I turned the key off, the dropoff was so dramatic.
It certainly SOUNDS like your blower is not engaging when it should, but based on how my car reacted when the pump was out completely, I'd think if the blower is not engaging at all below 3k rpm, the lack of power below 3k would be very obvious.
Measuring the gap with a feeler gauge seems to be of obvious importance, but even Code 3's instructions say "check the gap between the backplate and the clutch. It should be between .20 and .30mm. The important point is that once tightened, the pulley and clutch spin freely of each other, while being as close as possible".
Before I added a shim yesterday, the SC to backplate gap WAS under .20mm, but the SC did spin freely, and I could still stop the SC clutch with my bare hands when the engine was running. Makes me wonder if I really needed the shim at all?? Without the shim, the SC engagement was really smooth and undetectable when driving. It still is now that the shim is in, but it makes me wonder if there would be increased wear or stretching with the pulley springs.
I guess we'd also have to factor in some room to accommodate heat expansion, so who knows??
Anyway, I hope some of this might be of help.
When it was intermittent, the dropping in and out of the power increase SC provides was EXTREMELY noticeable... like when it went out, a Prius would probably have blown my doors off, and that might not even be an exaggeration.
Before I changed the circulator pump, when SC would disengage abruptly at or near full throttle, even my wife said "what the #&(@ was THAT"??? I mean, it felt like I turned the key off, the dropoff was so dramatic.
It certainly SOUNDS like your blower is not engaging when it should, but based on how my car reacted when the pump was out completely, I'd think if the blower is not engaging at all below 3k rpm, the lack of power below 3k would be very obvious.
Measuring the gap with a feeler gauge seems to be of obvious importance, but even Code 3's instructions say "check the gap between the backplate and the clutch. It should be between .20 and .30mm. The important point is that once tightened, the pulley and clutch spin freely of each other, while being as close as possible".
Before I added a shim yesterday, the SC to backplate gap WAS under .20mm, but the SC did spin freely, and I could still stop the SC clutch with my bare hands when the engine was running. Makes me wonder if I really needed the shim at all?? Without the shim, the SC engagement was really smooth and undetectable when driving. It still is now that the shim is in, but it makes me wonder if there would be increased wear or stretching with the pulley springs.
I guess we'd also have to factor in some room to accommodate heat expansion, so who knows??
Anyway, I hope some of this might be of help.
However if it is true then the springs have relaxed by more. As designed the springs hold the clutch plate against the stops, if the stops were removed the clutch plate would move even further away from the magnet, this is because the springs are preloaded to keep the clutch plate firmly against the stops. If the plate has moved and reduced the gap then there is now a gap between the plate and the stops.
If this is true then the gap will continue to get smalleruntil the plate rubs against the electromagnetic clutch. when the plate is not energized and the car idling.
One pulley was to be set up twice, an initial setting then when the springs had relaxed to set it up again, by this time the plate would not be sitting against the stops at all. I think that that would lead to the early failure of the springs because they were not springs at all. The OEM springs are much thinner than the after market springs because they are real springs, the others get their strength by being thicker only. I do not know if the springs on later pulleys were improved.
My prediction of the after market pulley spring failures are being born out.
Some people poo poohed me at the time and later, and after some springs failed, said that was the price of improvement.
The OEM springs have to fail and have failed in some rare cases but that is just something that happens after continual flexing, it will happen much sooner in non spring material.
Re: Chirp from the sc clutch?
I've been noticing a consistent noise. I haven't really paid too much attention to it until now, but I think what I'm hearing is a chirp from the sc clutch engaging. It only happens in 1st gear when I'm in manual mode. It doesn't matter how fast or slow I accelerate, but when I hit right around 3k rpm, I hear a chirp and feel a massive shove in torque. I think before I thought that it was just wheel spin from the surge in torque, but now I think it's the clutch engaging. If I rev over the 3k and it happens and then decelerate and try to hit 3k to hear it again it doesn't happen, unless I come to a stop and accelerate again. Now, I've read a thread or two over on mbworld and they said the chirp was normal as the clutch and pulley age, but I would assume the clutch should be engaging somewhere between 1600-1800 rpm. If what I'm hearing is my clutch engaging, I don't know why it's not engaging until 3000 rpm. Should I be concerned? Any thoughts are appreciated.