Sounds fair to me.

I paid $19,990 for an '04 coupe. It has 25k miles. The reason I didn't look for a better deal was 1. It has brand new tires 2. The color I wanted (silver) 3. Dealer within driving distance of my house (ebay is great, but shipping is a pain in the nuts - plus they're within striking distance if they were to screw me - hard to sue a dealer 3,000 miles away).

I made them cough up a fair trade-in amount (they tried to lowball me by $1k).

I really love this car - it makes me feel like a friggin' king. I'm just so pissed my shift **** came off. Who has time to deal with this crap?