Go with the crossfire! I myself was once a honda fan, but none of the ones I've owned (prelude,H22 civic,4 door civic) come close to the ride quality of the crossfire! You really can tell they are made by MB. My girl's mother had the top of the line accord v6 ex leather and all and it still not in the same leage. I haven't had a chance to drive an S2000 but I know one of my friends about bought one and said he wasn't impressed with the power/TQ at all. Also in my neck of the woods the crossfire is rare and gets looks from young and old alike. It just depends on if your looking for something to modify or not. After my civic was stolen I had enough of the younger crowd eyeing my car and was ready to move to something more adult.