my friend loves the look of my srt6 roadster so much that shes considering a new toy. question

shes not a real motorhead but more into the style of her ride so which car is a better choice,a brand new '08 limited in classic yellow, which by the way we both love for 30k, OR a rare 2005 srt6 with 9k miles in pristine shape for 23.5k.

my opinion is the srt6 down the road will retain more of her investment despite the fact she would have to drop an xtra $1,500 or so to put a chrysler extended warranty on it. shes got her heart set on yellow and leaning towards the limited. while i would rather see her in the srt6 the limited in its last model year is in itself a rare ride, SO HELP HER OUT, lets hear what you all think.