Thanks for the advice guys. I ended up getting the Goodyear Eagle F1 All Seasons. I'm a little worried about the reported noise, especially considering that I think the Conti's on it now are noisy. Oh well, the price was right. I ended up ordering them from a local tire shop. They were only slightly more than TireRack.com, and a bundle cheaper than Sam's Club.

Hmmm....I've never burned rubber on this car because I didn't want to wear out my tires. Now that I'm getting a new set soon, maybe I'll take it out and have a little fun with the old ones.