I have a stick & and a automatic, the stick is faster......BUT, this is probably only true if the 2 cars are side by side & both parties know that they are all out racing. What happens in the every day real world is....you just don't feel right reving it up & dropping the clutch at every stop light. It's difficult to explain but in the automatic in normal every day driving (away from a stop light) it's less drama to get going ...but, no question about it....in full ***** out mode the stick will beat the automatic version...there's a lot to be said for the automatic though....
if the stick guy is not on top of his game ...the automatic guy (if he has his left foot on the brake & gives it a little gas & as the light changes let off the brake just as you stomp the gas)...will win.
I don't care what the EPA #s say, the stick gets better MPG also!