Same thing happened to me as in the OP.

I put the STorage Bin in (that was offered in the base model). I use it to keep my wallet in so I don't give myself a hernia trying to get my wallet outta my pocket while sitting in my air-conditioned, smaller than a go-kart, Crossfire Roadster.

If ya know what you are doing, you can replace the cupholder with the bin yourself in 20 minutes. (Of course, it took me 50 minutes - but if I have to do it again - it'll be a breeze the next time).

The bin was $68 at my dealer, they discounted it to $52 with tax. You can order them online for $28.