IMO, the car as you have described it is worth no more than $25K, and that would be on the extreme high side.... Paying a big premium for the like new condition, and documentation. It is sad, but also reality. Low mileage clean SRT Roadsters can be had for $17 - $20K all day long. For $35K, you can buy 2 SRT Roadsters with less than 30K miles on them. I paid $18.5K for mine a little over a year ago, and it had 22K miles on her at the time. I now have 26K miles on her.

I was drooling as I was reading your description of the car, and would love to own a pristine example like that, but not for that price.

Good luck.