I went and saw the car yesterday. It was buffed, and every body panel has orange peel. And dust embedded in the finish. And divots from where larger particles of dust/dirt were buffed out... The wheels were painted a different color(silver, but a flat silver not the sparkly silver the OEM wheels are), had runs and they hadn't cleaned the dirt/brake dust off the inside of the wheels - they just painted over it...

And the owner of the shop wouldn't even discuss it. When I mentioned the orange peel, he immediately said he'd call my insurance company to have somebody come look at the car...