"My wheel fell off and I lost control and drove through the coffee shop" and Dave's Tire and Lube was the one that put it on the car...

Here's the information you need to give your wheel person..

Bolt Pattern - Offset - Center Bore - Man. Part #

5x112 +50mm 72.60mm 437-880-4450BK (your 18" wheels)

stock front 35mm 66.56mm ( Crossfire OEM Wheel)

From reading other threads you "should" be able to get away with using your current spacer with just the hub centric rings.

EDIT: Tried to get those to line up in columns but I now give up.. LOL