Went with aftermarket.. Fit and finish looks perfect! Guess you could have doubled my cost with OEM new.. "Personally" if I was in your shoes.. I'd be sourcing parts myself and taking care of it if that's an option with your insurance company.. (I'm guessing covered).. if not.. no doubt which way I'd go.. I'd probably go to some body shops and see about inspecting some of the finish paint work on cars they had.. Just let them know up front and if they balk.. time to walk..