Originally Posted by
onehundred80
You are correct, it does not sound like a shifter problem at all. Most likely the plate in the tranny, I had a 300 and it had similar problems with a similar tranny that got worse over time, days actually. Solenoid was rebuilt by dealer and the problem was gone.
It was the shifter. I bought one from eBay and replaced the old one and bam everything is working fine. I'm lucky I guess the stealership told me 3k and I got it done for like 350 total. Thanks for the help though !