Last night I was enjoying some beers and came across a thread where someone was very convincing that Hagerty was a great option in saving money on insurance for pleasure cars. Anyway, as of last night Progressive was charging me around 1K per year to insure my supercharged '07 SLK55 (yes, I had the mods added to my coverage). Anyway, I checked Hagerty for sh's and giggles and was very surprised at the result. I'm now paying Hagerty under $500 per year for the same coverage per year versus twice as much.

 

If you are a veteran look at USAA. If not look at Amica. They are highly rated in payouts, service and price.

Geico and Progressive can't possibly be inexpensive with all the advertising that they do.

 

Been with Hagerty for 7 years now.

 

" If you are a veteran look at USAA. If not look at Amica. They are highly rated in payouts, service and price."

Don't waste your time with USAA. I have both cars insured with them currently. I decided to check rates and place the XFIRE with a classic/collectible company and save money. Contacted USAA, discussed whether they had a company under their umbrella (for obvious reasons - we have 4 other bundled policies with them) that would meet this need. They use American Collectors Insurance. I was transferred over to that division, and after a lengthy discussion was informed the maximum value they would insure a crossfire for was $8175. This was with an excellent record, garage, no tickets, accidents, blah blah blah. Absolutely insane ! Now I'm going to use either American Modern or Haggerty.


Here's a link with an excellent overview of the various companies and their restrictions: https://www.valuepenguin.com/best-cl...-car-insurance