Exhaust size:Correct me if i'm wrong.
okay, seeing all the variations of exhausts on here, and with our own miserable attempts at making a more 'potent' exhaust, i was mulling something over....
in high powered SINGLE exhaust cars running boost like Toyota supras, STi's etc.... i most commonly see SINGLE 3" exhaust upgrades.
NOW. if we were running TRUE DUALS on our boosted SRT's, doesn't building 2.5" exhaust on EACH side actually equate to 5" of exhaust??? and is this an incorrect statement?
wouldn't maybe something more tame such as 2" exhaust on each side with no cats provide a better "BALANCE" of power delivery?
i mean, if AMG fitted us with a single 2.75" single exhaust from the factory, (which equates to 1.37" per side) and still allows for a lot of power, are we all getting too greedy with the exhaust volume?
in high powered SINGLE exhaust cars running boost like Toyota supras, STi's etc.... i most commonly see SINGLE 3" exhaust upgrades.
NOW. if we were running TRUE DUALS on our boosted SRT's, doesn't building 2.5" exhaust on EACH side actually equate to 5" of exhaust??? and is this an incorrect statement?
wouldn't maybe something more tame such as 2" exhaust on each side with no cats provide a better "BALANCE" of power delivery?
i mean, if AMG fitted us with a single 2.75" single exhaust from the factory, (which equates to 1.37" per side) and still allows for a lot of power, are we all getting too greedy with the exhaust volume?
Interesting question. Maybe Professor Waldig or another educated motorhead can answer your well thought question. I hope to get whatever exhaust I end up with before I get my custom tune so I can take advantage of the changes. Does that make sense?
Originally Posted by j-fire
okay, seeing all the variations of exhausts on here, and with our own miserable attempts at making a more 'potent' exhaust, i was mulling something over....
in high powered SINGLE exhaust cars running boost like Toyota supras, STi's etc.... i most commonly see SINGLE 3" exhaust upgrades.
NOW. if we were running TRUE DUALS on our boosted SRT's, doesn't building 2.5" exhaust on EACH side actually equate to 5" of exhaust??? and is this an incorrect statement?
wouldn't maybe something more tame such as 2" exhaust on each side with no cats provide a better "BALANCE" of power delivery?
i mean, if AMG fitted us with a single 2.75" single exhaust from the factory, (which equates to 1.37" per side) and still allows for a lot of power, are we all getting too greedy with the exhaust volume?
in high powered SINGLE exhaust cars running boost like Toyota supras, STi's etc.... i most commonly see SINGLE 3" exhaust upgrades.
NOW. if we were running TRUE DUALS on our boosted SRT's, doesn't building 2.5" exhaust on EACH side actually equate to 5" of exhaust??? and is this an incorrect statement?
wouldn't maybe something more tame such as 2" exhaust on each side with no cats provide a better "BALANCE" of power delivery?
i mean, if AMG fitted us with a single 2.75" single exhaust from the factory, (which equates to 1.37" per side) and still allows for a lot of power, are we all getting too greedy with the exhaust volume?
Originally Posted by c32AMG-DTM
I believe that to, in fact, be an incorrect statement. The cross-section area of the tube would be pi*r^2. 3.14 * 1.25 * 1.25 = 4.91 inches of area. So, duals would be 9.8125" of total area. By comparison, 3.14 * 2.5 * 2.5 = 19.625" of total area. In conclusion, the single 5" exhaust tube would flow WAY more than two 2.5" exhaust tubes.
much of tuning is like making a cake; too much of an ingredient, it's ruined. too little of an ingredient, it's ruined.
again, why aren't we seeing turbo-supras running 4-5" exhausts? i've seen numerous with 700-800hp supras with 3" single exhausts.
thoughts?
Originally Posted by j-fire
but.... is that necessarily a GOOD thing? seems like we may be getting too much flow.
much of tuning is like making a cake; too much of an ingredient, it's ruined. too little of an ingredient, it's ruined.
again, why aren't we seeing turbo-supras running 4-5" exhausts? i've seen numerous with 700-800hp supras with 3" single exhausts.
thoughts?
much of tuning is like making a cake; too much of an ingredient, it's ruined. too little of an ingredient, it's ruined.
again, why aren't we seeing turbo-supras running 4-5" exhausts? i've seen numerous with 700-800hp supras with 3" single exhausts.
thoughts?
But that is an interesting cake comparison.
Originally Posted by c32AMG-DTM
I believe that to, in fact, be an incorrect statement. The cross-section area of the tube would be pi*r^2. 3.14 * 1.25 * 1.25 = 4.91 inches of area. So, duals would be 9.8125" of total area. By comparison, 3.14 * 2.5 * 2.5 = 19.625" of total area. In conclusion, the single 5" exhaust tube would flow WAY more than two 2.5" exhaust tubes.
Don't ask me how to pronounce Poiseuille, I have no idea.
Originally Posted by sonoronos
Hagen-Poiseuille states that airflow through a tube is the fourth power of radius. This means that a 5" exhaust would flow 8x more gas than 2 2.5" exhaust tubes.
Don't ask me how to pronounce Poiseuille, I have no idea.
Don't ask me how to pronounce Poiseuille, I have no idea.
Click the "Hear" button
Something about "homegenous fluid" VS ever-changing exhaust gas temperatures has me scratching my head....
Honestly any gains from exhaust "upgrades" are minor mostly its just a tone and volume preferance. I personaly kept the 2 cats, 2 resonators, and 3 way cat on, but removed the muffler and ran a Y-splitter out the back for a more agressive "muscle" sound and enjoy it very much.
I think exhaust size makes more of a difference on turbo cars than SC cars. In a turbo application you are trying to provide the right amount of back pressure, so as to get the most flow and less restriction in the exhaust. This should make the turbo more efficient.
the point i'm trying to make, is perhaps we are trying to use too much 'larger' pipe, and maybe for a 'true dual exhaust' we should use 2" or 2.25" on both sides, instead of 3" on both sides! 3" of exhaust pipe on only 3 cylinder heads each side seems excessive, and maybe is not 'balancing' the power curve.
Originally Posted by REVIT93RX7
I think exhaust size makes more of a difference on turbo cars than SC cars. In a turbo application you are trying to provide the right amount of back pressure, so as to get the most flow and less restriction in the exhaust. This should make the turbo more efficient.
Originally Posted by j-fire
the point i'm trying to make, is perhaps we are trying to use too much 'larger' pipe, and maybe for a 'true dual exhaust' we should use 2" or 2.25" on both sides, instead of 3" on both sides! 3" of exhaust pipe on only 3 cylinder heads each side seems excessive, and maybe is not 'balancing' the power curve.
Originally Posted by ProjectMayhem
I personaly kept the 2 resonators
Last edited by Mimi05SRT6; Feb 19, 2009 at 01:59 AM.
Originally Posted by Mimi05SRT6
That's weird...For some reason I only have 1 resonator on my car which came like that from the factory. 

Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Idrenak
Parts/Accessories for sale - Archive
6
Sep 19, 2015 08:17 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)




